Sparkling Wine For Old Year and New

Sparkling wine corks

The turning of the year calls for a special libation

On New Year’s Eve we pause on the rim of the calendar, Janus-like, looking back and looking ahead. We contemplate past victories and sins, and we forecast prosperity and hope.

We mark this transition with a toast, opening what will become the old year’s last — and the new year’s first — sparkling wine. Let’s make it a good one.

There are lots of ways to add fizz to wine, and the results are always fun. But for auspicious moments like these I lean on méthode traditionnelle wines, which get their bubbles from a second fermentation in the bottle, and méthode ancestrale wines, (also called pétillant-naturel), which are bottled before the first fermentation exhales its last gas.

Such bottle conditioning builds in depth and savoriness from the lees contact, making these sparklers especially delicious for celebratory toasts. But the style feels right in another way, too, because although the wines are fully modern, they rely on methods that are old-fangled and ancestral, harkening a bygone time.

Auld Lang Syne, baby. And happy 2018.


A Celebration of Sparkling Wine

Below are thirteen bottle-conditioned sparkling wine options from recent tastings. Two are true champagnes I think are solid values. Eight are wines from elsewhere in France (which must be called called crémant), Spain (cava), Italy (metodo classico), and England (just plain sparkling). I’ve also included four American pét-nats because they are insanely delicious if marginally available; ask your favorite merchant for similar options. The wines are ordered by price from lowest to highest. Click the wine name to find my original review; you can also browse all recent sparkling wine reviews by visiting the Sparkling Wines category.

NV U Mes U Fan Tres Cygnus Cava Brut Nature Reserva

Lemony-crisp with a twist of citrus, this un-dosed cava has a creamy, toasty bass note. $20

NV Marie-Pierre Manciat Crémant De Bourgogne Brut

One hundred percent Chardonnay from great Burgundian soil, this wine is rich with candied citrus peels, pastry, hazelnuts, and brioche. $21

NV Domaine Allimant-Laugner Brut Rosé Crémant d’Alsace

Spirited and spring-like, with a sense of field strawberry and mint, this crémant is great for snacks and finger foods. $21

Rosé sparkling wine

2016 Onward Malvasia Pétillant Naturel Capp Inn Ranch Suisun Valley

A genius sparkler based on Malvisia bianca, whose white-floral essence earns depth and savoriness from the bottle conditioning. $24

2015 La Garagista Ci Confonde White Pétillant Naturel Vermont

This pét-nat is based on the Brianna grape; it’s honeyed and grassy, like a wildflower meadow in late summer. $25

2015 La Garagista Ci Confonde Rosé Pétillant Naturel Vermont

Frontenac Gris makes a brilliant light red rosé pét-nat that reads like a mélange of strawberries and rose petals. $25

NV Dopff & Irion Cuvée Prestige Elegance Brut Crémant d’Alsace

This Alsatian crémant crackles with lime-y acidity and notes of white flowers, lemon peel, and salty minerals. $25

Blanc de blancs or blanc de noirs sparkling wine

2013 Vignoble Des 2 Lunes Comète Brut Crémant d’Alsace

Made from biodynamically farmed Pinot Blanc, this crémant is foamy and snappy, with a suggestion of baked nut and pear. $25

2016 Onward Pinot Noir Rosé Pétillant Naturel Hawkeye Ranch Redwood Valley

A seriously delicious pét-nat of Pinot Noir with an essence of tangerine, fresh berries, peaches, and leesy savoriness. $30

NV Bernard Remy Carte Blanche Brut Champagne

This lavish champagne, made by a small house, really has everything going on: fruit, toast, nut, pastry. $37

NV Champagne Collet Brut Art Déco Champagne

Quietly sparkling, this champagne has a body opulent with amaretto, cherrystone, plum fruit, and roasted nut. $42

2013 Ridgeview Blanc De Noirs Brut England

And earthy, savory sparkler from Sussex, England, offering stony aromatics that are lifted by peaches and citrus. $50

2008 Fratelli Lunelli Ferrari Perlé Nero Trentodoc

One hundred percent Pinot Nero from the Dolomites, this vintage wine is heady with roasted hazelnuts, pastry, and pink berries. Truly celebratory. $80


Most wines were samples for review. See details on individual review pages.

Tags from the story
, , ,
More from Meg Maker
Two As One
I don't usually go for specialty ingredients. My food philosophy, such as...
Read More
2 replies on “Sparkling Wine For Old Year and New”
  1. says: David B

    What time do you open the “good stuff”on NYE? I tend to drink the better wine early, and use a less expensive sparkler for the midnight toast (if I am still awake).

    1. Truthfully, for me the point is to mark the moment. We tend to celebrate with a single bottle early-ish and go to bed by ten, by which time it’s midnight somewhere over the Atlantic, which is good enough for us.

      Happy new year, David.

Comments are closed.